Tubetotext

    Gayatri Spivak’s “Can the Subaltern Speak”

    Critique of Deleuze and Foucault

    Spivak is suspicious of the idea of a free-floating subject that can shed their identity away, as this disregards the fact that many people are marked by their race, gender, and class.

    13:53

    Limitations of Deleuze and Foucault's Theories

    Deleuze and Foucault's theories do not take into account the international division of labor and the ways in which capitalist exploitation shapes people's lives.

    16:36

    Marx's Concept of Class

    Marx's concept of class is not a collective one, but rather a class comprised of splits and breaks and ruptures.

    19:04

    Spivak's Critique of Deleuze and Foucault

    Spivak opposes Deleuze and Foucault's ideas because she believes they erase representation and ignore the signifier, which is a key concept in post-structuralism.

    19:56

    Colonization and the Subject-Object Split

    Spivak argues that the subject-object split is a product of Western colonization, where the colonizer assumes superiority over the colonized and creates an 'other' that is inferior and dependent

    34:32

    The Responsibility of White Men

    Spivak critiques the idea that white men have a responsibility to 'save' brown women from brown men, as this perpetuates a colonial and patriarchal power dynamic

    37:00

    Erasure of Indian Culture

    The erasure of Indian culture and the sati tradition is a result of British colonialism, which imposed its own ideas of what is good and proper on Indian society.

    38:54

    The Complexities of Sati

    Sati, or the practice of widow immolation, was not just a simple act of self-sacrifice, but was complex and multi-layered, with multiple motivations and meanings.

    40:02

    The Death of Bhuvaneswari Bhaduri

    The death of Bhuvaneswari Bhaduri, a young woman who was a member of a militant group fighting for Indian independence, was a complex and mysterious event that has been the subject of much speculation and interpretation.

    46:15

    The Subaltern and the Voiceless

    The subaltern, or the voiceless, is a concept that refers to those who are marginalized and excluded from the dominant discourse of society.

    46:52